The Pennington School celebrates numerous student-athletes who have committed to teams at colleges or universities for the fall of 2024. 

Hailey Adamsky will be playing soccer in the Ivy League at University of Pennsylvania–Wharton, and Keane Brown (US Naval Academy), Justin Davidyock (US Military Academy at West Point), Kieran Karp (University of South Carolina), Morgan Kotch (Villanova University), Matthew Lynch (Rutgers University), and Kendall Malmros (Fordham University) will all be playing Division I soccer. Also continuing their soccer careers in college are Pablo Carnicer Cozar, who will play at the Division II level at University of Tampa, as well as Felix Shapiro and Sophia Murphy, who will both play for Division III teams, Shapiro at Carleton College and Murphy at Stevens Institute of Technology. Dowon Zio Kim has committed to playing Ivy League basketball at Princeton University and Morgan Matthews will be playing Division I basketball at George Washington University. Bryce Meccage has committed to Division I baseball at University of Virginia and Emma Nelson has committed to Division I field hockey at Quinnipiac University. Paloma Szyfer will also continue her field hockey career at Oberlin College at the Division III level. Also playing at the Division III level are Polaris Hayes, who will play tennis at California Institute of Technology; and Quaadir Durden and Nicholas Esposito, lacrosse, who will play at College of Wooster and Hampden-Sydney College, respectively.